1672-8505

CN 51-1675/C

李兆杰, 牛艳. 司法改革视域下专业法官会议的价值分析、存在问题及优化路径——基于全国36个地方法院的专业法官会议实践的研究[J]. 西华大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2016, 35(2): 79-86.
引用本文: 李兆杰, 牛艳. 司法改革视域下专业法官会议的价值分析、存在问题及优化路径——基于全国36个地方法院的专业法官会议实践的研究[J]. 西华大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2016, 35(2): 79-86.
LI Zhao-jie, NIU Yan. An Analysis of the Professional Judges' Meeting:Its Values, Problems and Optimal Ways out —A Case Study Based on the Professional Judges' Meeting of 36 Local Courts[J]. Journal of Xihua University (Philosophy & Social Sciences) , 2016, 35(2): 79-86.
Citation: LI Zhao-jie, NIU Yan. An Analysis of the Professional Judges' Meeting:Its Values, Problems and Optimal Ways out —A Case Study Based on the Professional Judges' Meeting of 36 Local Courts[J]. Journal of Xihua University (Philosophy & Social Sciences) , 2016, 35(2): 79-86.

司法改革视域下专业法官会议的价值分析、存在问题及优化路径——基于全国36个地方法院的专业法官会议实践的研究

An Analysis of the Professional Judges' Meeting:Its Values, Problems and Optimal Ways out —A Case Study Based on the Professional Judges' Meeting of 36 Local Courts

  • 摘要: 专业法官会议是一项法律没有明确规定、但已在司法实践中广泛实施的一种审判咨询制度。专业法官会议制度具有公平正义的价值属性,契合司法改革内容,有利于培育专家型法官。它作为司法改革的一项重要的辅助制度,对推进司法改革具有重大意义。优化专业法官会议制度应当客观分析研究制度运行效果,积极回应法官质疑,吸纳合理建议,从性质、设置、功能等静态要素和人员组成、议事范围、提起和决定、议事规则、意见的效力及校正等动态要素两大方面进行完善,以期建构顺应司法规律、能够为主审法官及合议庭独立办案提供有效智力支持的制度。

     

    Abstract: Professional judges' meeting is a trial advisory system though not having been clearly defined but gradually enriched and improved in judicial practice. Professional judges' meeting system has the value of fairness and justice, being in line with the content of judicial reform. It is helpful to cultivate expert judges. As an important auxiliary system of the judicial reform, it is of great significance in promoting judicial reform. Optimizing professional judges' conference system should make an analysis of the effect of running system objectively, responding to the question of judges actively, and taking the reasonable suggestions. In order to construct a system that can conform to the legal rule, it provides effective intellectual support for the work of the presiding judge, the collegial panel, from the static elements such as nature, setting, function and the dynamic elements such as personnel, the scope, filed and decision, the effectiveness of the rules of procedure, comments and correction.

     

/

返回文章
返回